Deep Cuts

Music writing for the long play

Long-form essays on bands who deserved more. One retrospective at a time — no hot takes, no listicles.

  1. Era essays

    Backwards: The Crusade Against Rock Music and the Artists Who Defied It

    Between 1979 and 1990, a small coalition of evangelical preachers, congressional spouses, and concerned parents convinced substantial portions of the American public that rock music was a deliberate satanic recruitment operation. They held album-burning ceremonies. They published books decoding backward-masked demonic messages in mainstream radio hits. They got the U.S. Senate to hold hearings. They sued Judas Priest for two suicides. The bands, watching the panic unfold around them, eventually started recording actual backward messages in their songs — sometimes as satire, sometimes as defiance, sometimes as a kind of dark joke at the panic's expense. The inaugural Era essay.

    By Deep Cuts · Issue 05 · · 15 min read

  2. One and Done

    Hanging On a Heart Attack: Holly Knight's Device and the Album That Was Almost the One She Wanted

    In 1986, one of the most accomplished songwriters of the MTV era assembled a band as her own creative vehicle, recruited a Mormon ex-missionary as lead vocalist, made a record at Cherokee Studios with Mike Chapman producing, watched the lead single reach number 35 on the Hot 100, and lost the project before the second single had finished its commercial cycle. A look at Device's 22B3 — the album where Holly Knight tried to be the artist rather than the writer, and the structural reasons the attempt did not produce the second album she had assumed would follow.

    By Deep Cuts · Issue 05 · · 22 min read

  3. Retrospective

    Rock Soldier: Ace Frehley's Post-KISS Decade and the Band That Was Best When It Was Least His Own

    The standard history files Ace Frehley's three post-KISS records as a redemption arc — a wreck cleans up, comes back strong in 1987, fumbles in 1988, reclaims himself in 1989. The facts are right and the reading is wrong. Frehley's Comet charted highest when it was least Frehley's own work, made its most competent record in the moment everyone calls its collapse, and sold least once it finally sounded like nobody but Ace. The decade didn't return the Spaceman to himself. It proved the Spaceman was a brand other hands could carry — and that 'Frehley's Comet' could be a band or a Frehley vehicle, never both.

    By Deep Cuts · Issue 05 · · 8 min read

  4. Retrospective

    Hit Me with Your Best Shot: Pat Benatar, Neil Giraldo, and the Twenty-Two-Year Hall of Fame Wait

    She was eligible for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2000. She was inducted in 2022. The twenty-two-year delay was not, by her own subsequent account, an accident — she had been turning down individual induction since the institution first became willing to consider her, refusing to accept the honor unless her musical partner and husband of forty years was inducted alongside her. The standard rock-history vocabulary has consistently positioned her as a solo MTV pop-rock vocalist whose commercial peak ended around 1985 and whose subsequent career has been a slow nostalgia-circuit decline. The accurate version is more interesting, substantially better documented, and centers a creative partnership the broader rock-criticism vocabulary has spent four decades failing to recognize.

    By Deep Cuts · Issue 05 · · 17 min read

  5. Retrospective

    The Quietest Disappearance: White Lion, Vito Bratta, and the Career That Ended When It Was Just Beginning

    Their second album sold two million copies and produced a number-three Hot 100 single. Their guitarist appeared on the cover of Guitar World and was widely positioned as the successor to Eddie Van Halen. Their fourth album was a substantial creative achievement that the marketplace declined to receive. The lead singer continues to perform their material into 2026. The guitarist has played in public exactly twice since 1991 — at a Brooklyn club reunion show in April 2007 — and has otherwise lived quietly on Staten Island for thirty-five years. A retrospective on White Lion, and on the fact that the band's most interesting story is what the guitarist did not do after September 1991.

    By Deep Cuts · Issue 05 · · 15 min read

  6. Era essays

    The Math of Refresh: How CMC International Made a Record Label Work in the 1990s by Refusing to Behave Like One

    By 1993, the major labels had collectively decided that hair metal, AOR, and the broader 1980s commercial-rock catalog was structurally finished as a viable commercial proposition. The math no longer worked. A typical major-label rock album required gold certification — 500,000 units sold — just to recoup recording costs, promotional budgets, and the broader overhead the major-label commercial infrastructure required. The bands that had been generating multi-platinum sales five years earlier could no longer reach gold certification reliably. The majors began dropping them in sequence across 1992, 1993, and 1994. Tom Lipsky and Bill Cain, operating out of an office in Raleigh, North Carolina, looked at the same financial math the majors had looked at and reached a different conclusion. They built a record label whose entire structural premise was that the conventional commercial-rock business model had become incompatible with what working bands at the post-collapse commercial tier actually needed. The label was called CMC International. It existed from 1991 to 2000. It signed approximately forty veteran rock and metal acts the majors had dropped or abandoned, and it made money doing so.

    By Deep Cuts · Issue 04 · · 12 min read

  7. Long Plays

    Wrong Decade, Wrong Closet, Wrong Building: Enuff Z'Nuff, Strength, and the 1991 Album That Was a Power-Pop Classic Disguised as Hair Metal

    Their 1989 debut sold half a million copies and produced two MTV hits. Their guitarist was a virtuoso who would die of an overdose at 37. Their lead singer was a Beatles-obsessed songwriter who would spend the next three decades fighting addiction while continuing to make some of the most accomplished power-pop records of his generation. Their manager was the same one who built Journey. Rolling Stone called them the Hot Band of 1991. The album that should have made them stars peaked at number 143 on the Billboard 200, sold a fraction of what its predecessor had sold, and was eventually parodied on Beavis and Butthead. A Long Play on Strength, the album doomed by the band's own visual presentation.

    By Deep Cuts · Issue 04 · · 13 min read

  8. Long Plays

    After Kyrie: Mr. Mister and the Album That Could Not Be Welcome to the Real World

    Their previous album had spent two weeks at number one on the Billboard 200 and produced two consecutive number-one Hot 100 singles. The follow-up, released twenty-two months later, peaked at number 55, generated one Top 30 single, and effectively ended the band's commercial career. The standard rock-history vocabulary calls Go On... a flop. The accurate framing is more complicated, and substantially more interesting.

    By Deep Cuts · Issue 04 · · 13 min read